Candidates Reveal Different Visions at West U Candidate Forum

April 10, 2015 By:George Boehme

Local News

Tiny town politics were on display for the hundred or so people in attendance at Wednesday night’s City Council Candidate Forum at West University Methodist Church. Eight candidates have signed-up to vie for four spots on the West University Place City Council. Current Mayor Pro-Tem Susan Sample is running unopposed for mayor.

Rev. Carol Bruse, Senior Pastor, welcomed the crowd of about 100 to the forum that was jointly sponsored by the West University Methodist Church, West U Democrats, and the Village News.

Each of the eight candidates delivered a three-minute opening statement, followed by a series of questions from Channel 13’s Tom Koch. Koch’s questions were followed by a one-minute response from each candidate. The candidates answered the questions in alphabetical order – Burt Ballanfant first, Mardi Turner last.

The questions were collected from the audience and the asked questions were chosen by Marie Monroe, from the West U Democrats, and Ben Ballanfant, junior partner and writer from the Village News (also candidate Burt Ballanfant’s son).

The biggest disagreement among the eight candidates was about the efficiency of West U’s municipal government.

The “slate” of four candidates – Ballanfant, Brennan Reilly, Turner and Bob Kelly – painted a portrait of inefficiency and a lack of transparency in West U’s municipal government. All four “slate” candidates were critical of the current mayor, city council, and city manager.

The four independent candidates – Bruce Beneke, Sonny Brandtner, Steven Segal and Phil Snyder – seemed to take the view that the execution of West U city services and the administration of West U municipal government are substantially efficient.

Other topics discussed –

West University Baptist Church Youth Center
“Slate” candidates Kelly, Reilly and Turner seemed to have reversed their earlier opposition to a church youth center proposed by West University Baptist Church. However, Ballanfant refused to state his opinion. The independent candidates have always supported allowing the youth center’s construction.

There seemed to be acknowledgement from all candidates that West University Baptist Church can, and will, build a youth facility. The question is where?

The Skinny: WUBC will either build its youth center on property the church now owns on the south side of Amherst Street that abuts the West U  City Hall parking lot where they already have city approval to operate the youth ministry center. Or they will trade that land to the City of West University Place for the land at 3826 Milton St. which is the current location of the 60-year-old Public Works Maintenance Facility. If the latter happens, WUBC would build the youth center at 3826 Milton St.

Relocation of the Public Works Maintenance Facility
The city council recently approved a plan to move the Public Works Maintenance Facility outside the city limits.

The facility, now housed at the corner of Milton and College, would move to the city’s now shuttered Recycle Express property on Dincans St. in the City of Houston. The public works maintenance operation houses solid waste and recycling, and the structure also is the home of a full-service vehicle and equipment repair and maintenance facility.

This proposed move is a topic of disagreement among the eight candidates. Ballanfant and Reilly oppose the move, while Snyder and Brandtner support relocating the city’s maintenance functions and vehicle storage lots outside the city limits.

The other candidates are less clear about their thoughts. However the “slate” is circulating a petition for forcing an election on the city’s decision to issue $3 million in bonds to finance the move of the Public Works Maintenance Facility and some other possible land purchases. If the petition is successful the city would have to seek voter approval of the bonds. Rather than force a vote, the WUBC has said it would instead construct its new youth ministry building on Amherst.

What wasn’t discussed

Outsourcing the Functions of the Public Works Maintenance Facility, Specifically the Vehicle Maintenance and Trash Collection
In the February 10 edition of the Village News, “slate”-members Kelly, Reilly and Turner opined that the city council should study the “cost savings that might be realized by outsourcing and not rebuilding” the Public Works Maintenance Facility.

These operations include the trash collection and recycling functions. It is also the storage area for crew trucks, the bucket truck, application equipment for the pavement marking. It includes a full-service vehicle and equipment repair and maintenance facility. The facility services police cars, trash trucks, street sweepers, jet spray trucks, trailer mounted generators (used for emergency power to sanitary sewer lift stations), compressors, excavators and backhoes, dump trucks, flatbeds, the seniors’ bus and various sedans.

Outsourcing of the public works functions and the possible service impacts to the residents from that action are likely to be controversial and were not discussed at the forum Wednesday night.

Purchase of Additional Parkland
For more than a decade, candidates Ballanfant and Turner have been West U’s leading advocates for acquisition of the “Ownby tract” for parkland. This tract includes 38,553 square feet of real estate where Pittsburg terminates at Poor Farm Ditch. The two lots, 3615 Pittsburg and 3619 Pittsburg, have been for sale for $3.6 million. The cost of the land acquisition and capital development of this proposed park could be between $7-$10 million. This issue is likely to be controversial and was not discussed at the forum.

Early voting by personal appearance will be conducted each weekday in the City Hall Council Chambers, 3800 University Blvd., between the hours of 8:00 a.m. and 5:00 p.m. on April 27 – May 1, 2015 and between the hours of 7:00 a.m. and 7:00 p.m. on May 4 – 5, 2015. On May 9, the polls will be open from 7am-7pm. and everyone in West U votes at West University City Hall, 3800 University Boulevard.

6 Responses to “Candidates Reveal Different Visions at West U Candidate Forum”

  1. Uncalled For Comments Says:

    Many of these comments are rude, especially DTR — you are rude, some of the things you have said here are personal and hurtful

  2. Lucille Gallman Says:

    Regarding the comment, “How can you call it legit when Burt Ballanfant got to answer every question first?”
    From what I understand, decisions about how the forum would be conducted were decided before the meeting. A representative from each of the entities hosting the forum would select the questions submitted by the audience: Marie Monroe – the West U Democrats and Ben Ballanfant – the Village News. Since some of the Ballanfant Family own The Village News, who besides a Ballanfant? There was no representative from West U Methodist Church. Alphabetical order determined which candidate answered the first question with each having a one-minute response after the first round of answers. Maybe it would have been better to put all he questions, which were probably many, in a box and have the moderator draw the questions asked. Also, to keep the whole process squeaky clean, perhaps the candidates could have drawn numbers indicating their place in line to answer the questions. I’ve been to these meetings where I submitted a question and none was ever used. I always took it personally. It will be interesting to see how the April 27 Candidate Forum is structured. Instant News West U and the West U Essentials Magazine are headed by George Boehme. I remember one where I think he selected the questions and called on the candidates who were sitting on the stage of the Community Building across the width of the stage. I guess we were just less complicated back then. Everyone laughed and enjoyed the meetings and genuinely liked and appreciated our neighbors who donated their time to keep West U nice.

  3. Lucille Gallman Says:

    Considering the future of West University Elementary School, Burt Ballanfant with his record of community service would be a good choice.

  4. David Kuykendall Says:

    The article fails to depict what actually happened during the forum. As with most forums, some candidates with pro this, or pro that, or failed to answer the question. However, it was clear that some were deeply committed, others superficial. Some had opinions derived from a thorough understanding of the issues, others seemed to have positions justified by a few bullet points memorized prior to the forum. Some showed passion, others not. Some seemed more willing than others to get resident input on major issues. These are important factors often missed by newspaper coverage.

    The article does not let readers get to know the candidates, and in some cases, might incorrectly report their positions. In an earlier comment on this blog, Lucille mentions the next candidate forum is April 27 from 7 to 9pm in the West U Community Building. Form your own opinion.

    Be there.

  5. Lucille Gallman Says:

    The West U Methodist Church, The Village News and the West U Democrats Club must have been pleased at the large attendance at the April 8 West U candidate forum. The moderator conducted the meeting in a professional manner that was appreciated by all. The next candidate forum meeting will be April 27 from 7 to 9 P.M. in the West U Community Building and will be hosted by Instant News West U and West U Essentials Magazine.

  6. Tangley Resident Says:

    Did I read this correctly? The questions were selected by the SON of one of the candidates? That is amazing. Only in West U.

    Was one of the questions, “Dad, what do you think about the other stupid candidates who aren’t as smart as you?”

    Politicians in Chicago would be outraged by this.

tumblr visitor stats