Shields May Have Violated Code Of Fair Campaign Practices

By: Sara Waisanen on Tue, Mar 15, 2011

News

Jim Shields

West U City Council candidate Jim Shields may have violated the Code of Fair Campaign Practices when he referred to incumbent Councilmember George Boehme as being “drunk” in an interview with InstantNewsWestU.

Shields told the news organization last week that part of the reason he was running for city council is because he was troubled when he read Ken Hoffman’s column in the Houston Chronicle about a council member who cut through a power line. He said the same council member also served alcohol to a minor.

“We don’t need people like that running our city,” said Shields, adding that the council member “had to be drunk when he did that” and “has a profound lack of common sense.” He’s not the guy I want to make decisions.”

While Shields did not mention the council member he was criticizing by name, he was apparently referring to Boehme, who is running for re-election.

Each candidate running for city council has the option to sign the Code of Fair Campaign Practices. The code is included in the candidate packets and subscription to the code is voluntary.

There is no way to enforce the code because candidates voluntarily sign it.

Records on file with the City of West University Place indicate that all candidates running for mayor and city council signed the Code of Fair Campaign Practices, including Shields.

“There are basic principles of decency, honesty, and fair play that every candidate and political committee in this state has a moral obligation to observe and uphold, in order that, after vigorously contested but fairly conducted campaigns, our citizens may exercise their constitutional rights to a free and untrammeled choice and the will of the people may be fully and clearly expressed on the issues,” according to the Code of Fair Campaign Practices.

Upon signing the code, candidates agree to the following:

-          I will conduct the campaign openly and publicly and limit attacks on my opponent to legitimate challenges to my opponent’s record and stated positions on issues.

-          I will not use or permit the use of character defamation, whispering campaigns, libel, slander, or scurrilous attacks on any candidate or the candidate’s personal or family life.

-          I will not use or permit any appeal to negative prejudice based on race, sex, religion, or national origin.

-          I will not use campaign material of any sort that misrepresents, distorts, or otherwise falsifies the facts, nor will I use malicious or unfounded accusations that aim at creating or exploiting doubts, without justification, as to the personal integrity or patriotism of my opponent.

-          I will not undertake or condone any dishonest or unethical practice that tends to corrupt or undermine our system of free elections or that hampers or prevents the full and free expression of the will of the voters, including any activity aimed at intimidating voters or discouraging them from voting.

-          I will defend and uphold the right of every qualified voter to full and equal participation in the electoral process, and will not engage in any activity aimed at intimidating voters or discouraging them from voting.

-          I will immediately and publicly repudiate methods and tactics that may come from others that I have pledged not to use or condone. I shall take firm action against any subordinate who violates any provision of this code or the laws governing elections.

After Shields filed for city council, InstantNewsWestU heard from a number of community members that Mayor Bob Kelly urged Shields to run against Boehme.

Kelly denied that was the case.

“I talked to Jim and I talked to many people about running,” Kelly said. “I did not talk to Jim Shields about running against George Boehme.”

Kelly told InstantNewsWestU that he thinks Boehme used poor judgment when he served alcohol to a minor and when he cut through a power line.

“I would not question anyone who runs against George Boehme because he has poor judgment,” said Kelly, adding that he did not have a problem with Shields comments about Boehme.

Tension rose between Kelly and Boehme in a series of public e-mails that were sent back and forth to each other on March 9.

In the e-mails, which were sent to InstantNewsWestU as well as other local media outlets, Boehme said that the mayor encouraged Shields to run and to take a “negative tack” against him.

“My life is an open book. If this guy stays in the race, his life will be an open book also,” Boehme said in his e-mail to Kelly.

Kelly responded by saying that Shields said Boehme’s statement are “absolutely false.”

“He also said that you were very rude to him and that you kept saying over and over again that you were very popular, would get the most votes in the council race, and that his running would only knock off some other candidate,” Kelly said in his reply to Boehme. “I would remind you that if Jim Shields wins a spot on council it will be because our citizens elected him. Your email below is also a very clear attempt to intimidate him from running from office.”

Boehme responded saying that he encourages “all citizens to run for office.”

“My concern is that Mr. Shields is a pawn in your Machiavellian Mutt and Jeff routine,” Boehme said.

Kelly replied saying that Boehme’s concerns about Shields “appear to be of your own making.”

“It is however my opinion that you have made a clear threat against one of our citizens in an attempt to get him to withdraw from running for city council….with your comment: ‘If this guy stays in the race, his life will be an open book also,’” Kelly said in his e-mail.

The e-mail chain was forwarded to Shields who responded to Kelly with this comment:

“I told George as clearly as I could that his actions involving the chain saw, ladder, and power line, and selling alcohol to minors were part of what inspired me to run. I told George that those actions alone speak for themselves and indicated to me that he has a profound lack of common sense and good judgment,” Shields said in his e-mail. “You sensed that he was trying to intimidate me and I must admit that I was waiting for him to threaten me which he never did. He was bellicose but I suspected that he had been drinking and it was the alcohol speaking. I even asked George if he had been drinking and he said that he rarely drinks. Could have fooled me.”

Boehme replied with this statement:

“Jim, your characterization of our conversation would, in my opinion, tend to make me think you are delusional and would not make a good city council member,” Boehme said in his e-mail.

West U voters will elect a mayor and four council members to serve two-year terms on May 14. Council candidates run for positions at large.

Shields is out of the country and was not available for comment.

16 Responses to “Shields May Have Violated Code Of Fair Campaign Practices”

  1. Oh Please. Says:

    I have heard enough from this guy to say no. Nice people don’t make these kind of accusations. He sounds an whole lot like Bob Kelly. I am glad George did not get down in the mud with them.

    Reply

  2. Anonymous Says:

    like i said in another post, jim, bob, and george are unfit for office

    Reply

  3. Neighborhood Gal Says:

    George certainly didn’t do anything wrong here. Shields and Kelly are scting like bullies. If you don’t want to vote for George then don’t. I happen to like him, even with a wort or two. But there is no excuse for Kelly and Shield’s conduct.

    Reply

  4. Lucille Gallman Says:

    Did Jim Shields know what he said during the interview would be printed?

    Reply

  5. Lucille Gallman Says:

    I just read in the online version of The Village-Southwest News that Jim Shields “served in the army in Germany and was a captain in Vietnam where he won the Bronze Star.” Frankly, I think that anyone who has combat experience can handle himself on the West University Place City Council. In fact, I think combat experience should be required.

    Reply

    • Ms. Pat Malone Says:

      I agree with Lucille. It could also be listed in the Code as having filled the certification requirements to verbally abuse.

      Thank you.
      Ms.Pat Malone

      Reply

  6. West U Resident Says:

    Mr. Shields military service is admirable (And remember John Kerry has three Purple Hearts). But Shiled’s ridiculous statements are not admirable. Many of us know and like George and do not appreciate these comments. The good news about Bob Kelly getting off the city council is that the bickering will stop. (George seems to get along great with everyone besides Kelly) We don’t need a Kelly clone on the next council.

    Reply

  7. HoustonLeghorn Says:

    Bob Kelly is the lush in this story. I didn’t know Bob drank until one day I saw him sober. I am sure Mr. Shield’s is a nice man who just was led down the primrose path by Bob Kelly.

    Reply

  8. Teacher's Pet Says:

    I rarely post on this things. But my first thought when I read this was what business does Bob Kelly have criticizing anyone’s drinking? One would think Bob would follow the old biblical passage, “Let he without sin, cast the first stone.” Bob, this is one you really should have left alone.

    Reply

  9. Laura Says:

    It is hard to argue Shields did not violate the Code Of Fair Campaign Practices. I think he likely has Bob Kelly to blame.

    Reply

  10. Sick of West U Officials Says:

    What a bunch of embarassing goofs. It makes me want to have a drink right now!

    Reply

  11. Mary Mason Says:

    I think this sort of attack politics is unwanted in West U. George may not be perect, but he does an excellent job and is the only person on the council that comunicates with the residents.

    Reply

  12. 28 year Resident Says:

    Bob Kelly is mean-spirited. Who is Jim Shields? If Mr. Shiels is quoted correctly, he should apologize to George.

    Reply

  13. Love thy neighbor Says:

    The one thing I do know is that George has always been supportive of West University Elementary. He has helped the school whenever asked without question. Also the story by Ken was written in his familiar humerous nature as is his signature trademark. It was not condemnation but a view of a good hearted neighbor making an honest mistake. If you are without fault then you far than I. Why such remarks are ever uttered is beyond me. As the oldage goes…”if can’t say anything nice don’t say anything at all.”.

    Reply

  14. WestUSue Says:

    Curly, Larry and Mo. How unfortunate that West U has such a limited choice of quality people to make decisions on our behalf.

    Reply

  15. Tangley Resident Says:

    Sue, you have at least one out of three right; Bob Kelly is definitely a stooge. I don’t know about Shields (I tend to think Shields in Kelly’s alter-ego). But I feel stronglly that Boehme is an very good councilmember. Just go to a meeting, he is always prepared. Everyone on the council is good. But Kelly is a mess.

    Reply


Leave a Reply