
Councilmember Steven Segal and Mayor Pro Tem Bob Fry are running for mayor. Council candidates include Susan Sample, George Boehme, Ed Heathcott, Joan Johnson, Dick Yehle and Jim Shields.
InstantNewsWestU is hosting an online candidate forum for the West U City Council candidates.
Questions and the candidates’ answers will be published throughout the weeks leading up to the May 14 election.
Councilmember Steven Segal and Mayor Pro Tem Bob Fry are running for mayor.
Council candidates include Susan Sample, George Boehme, Ed Heathcott, Joan Johnson, Dick Yehle and Jim Shields.
Readers who wish to submit questions for the candidates should e-mail them to [email protected].
Candidates’ answers are published as they are received, without any editing by InstantNewsWestU.
Question:
How well do you think the current city council and mayor have handled the restrictor issue?
The City of West U has been notified that about 4.4 acre-feet of detention is available for purchase by the city for $403,700. If the city purchases the detention space, the restrictor at the end of the pipe at Poor Farm Ditch could be reduced by about 1/3.
Do you think the city should take advantage of this opportunity?
What other steps should be taken to remove the last 2/3 of the restrictor?
Steven Segal:
The Harris County Flood Control District requires a City to provide “detention” before additional water from an improved drainage system is allowed to flow into Braes Bayou.
The West U Staff developed and presented a plan to HCFCD asserting that HCFCD should provide the required detention at no cost to West U because our drainage improvements provided regional benefits to other jurisdictions within the HCFCD. The last two Councils approved the Staff’s Plan and submission to HCFCD.
Last week HCFCD denied our position but stated, subject to certain approvals, West U could purchase a portion of the required detention from HCFCD.
YES, we should take all necessary action to complete payment for the 4.4 acre-feet of detention ($403,700) and remove the pro rata portion of the restrictor ASAP.
We should accelerate our search for the balance of the required detention, enabling us to remove the remainder of the restrictor. We should consider purchase of detention, if available, and explore additional options, including the widening of Kilmarneck Ditch, which our City owns, from Bellaire Blvd. to Braes Bayou, to provide additional detention. We should move aggressively to find a way to remove the restrictor.
Bob Fry:
“How well do you think the current city council and mayor have handled the restrictor issue?”
The restrictor issue began well before the current council was took office. Many of the decisions had already been made. During its time in office this Council has done everything it could to speed up a process. The rebuilding our infrastructure over the past few years has greatly improved the drainage of the entire city. Our experts tell us that what has been done to this point has improved our drainage in the College Street area by over 160%. The last piece of the flood control project is removing the restrictor to protect us from the infrequent “extreme” event. We have accomplished everything the city can do in this regard and now must work with other parties in the county and in neighboring cities. While this complicates the process and slows it down we are still making progress. Additionally Council can direct staff to explore any and all other options.
The City of West U has been notified that about 4.4 acre-feet of detention is available for purchase by the city for $403,700. If the city purchases the detention space, the restrictor at the end of the pipe at Poor Farm Ditch could be reduced by about 1/3. Do you think the city should take advantage of this opportunity?
Absolutely.
What other steps should be taken to remove the last 2/3 of the restrictor?”
We must use the right approach at the right times. The most effective approach now is to build coalitions with the other political entities that have a stake in further drainage improvement while exploring other possible options we can control.
Susan Sample:
“How well do you think the current city council and mayor have handled the restrictor issue?”
The College Street drainage project was approved in 2006. The funds for this project were provided primarily by Metro and Harris County, with the condition that mitigation would be required. Since WUP did not want to forego this funding opportunity, it accepted the county’s mitigation terms and moved forward with the project.
Because of the terms accepted in 2006, the current mayor and city council have been faced with finding ways to remove the temporary restrictor that was placed in the storm sewer outfall. I am not on the current city council, so I am not intimately familiar with the all of the efforts made by the mayor, city council and the city manager to facilitate removal of the restrictor.
It is a positive step, however, that the HCFCD recently notified WUP of 4.4 acres (out of our required 13.5 acres) of detention space available for sale to the city for $403,700. Assuming Harris County Commissioners Court approves this sale to WUP, we will be able to reduce the restrictor size by approximately one-third.
“What other steps should be taken to remove the last 2/3 of the restrictor?”
I support removal of the remainder of the restrictor and believe that an immediate study of additional remediation alternatives is warranted, including modifications to the Kilmarnock ditch in West University, to see if upgrades to this ditch could provide the required detention at lower than the $91,000 per acre foot cost in Meyer Tract.
George Boehme:
One of the fundamental purposes of our municipal government is to protect West University Place from flooding. We do this by participating in a storm water management system with Harris County Flood Control District (HCFCD).
Thanks to the City’s infrastructure replacement program, we all have a new, two-year event system, the recommended standard for this eight county region. For comparison, we now have more than 2 ½-times the below street storm water storage capacity than we did prior to Tropical Storm Allison. That is huge. The only problem is that one area still has a temporary water flow restrictor that was attached during construction. So today, some residents have a system that is slightly inferior to the rest of West University Place. In order to remove the flow restrictor, we have to purchase flood detention credits for about $1.2 million.
Do we spend the money?
The funding source for the acquisition of the 13.5 acre feet will not require any additional debt. The capital should come from the $259,000 in mobility funds we receive annually from METRO. We have about $500,000 on hand from this source, and we will continue to receive payments until 2013 for a total of about $1.3 million. But that is a heck of a lot of money that could be spent on other things.
So for me the question is a little different:
Do our neighbors in the College Street area deserve the same effective storm water management system as the rest of West U?
If the answer is yes, then we must spend the money to purchase the detention credits because they are required to get the water flow restrictor removed. People can argue to various effects that are presented in the different engineering hypotheticals. But my view is that our neighbors near College Street deserve the same modern storm water system as the rest of us. And all this fussing and cussing distract from the goal. So let’s work together to remove the restrictor ASAP.
Ed Heathcott:
As a result of the Allison flood in 2001, the West U City Council initiated engineering studies to determine the extent of required drainage improvement. Since Harris County Flood Control District, HCFCD, did not have funds to participate in an area wide drainage improvement, West University made plans to upgrade drainage as per the engineering studies. The restrictor was a known item at the time the project began and I agree it would not have been prudent to delay the drainage improvements until the restrictor issue was resolved. I agree the City should purchase the 4.4 acre feet of detention currently being offered by HCFCD. The City Manager is continuing the negotiations with HCFCD and others and I have full confidence an agreement will be reached where the remaining portion of the restrictor will be removed. Realistically, I do believe the final solution will cost the City additional funds. As mayor of Jersey Village in dealing with the flooding of Allison, I formed a trusting relationship with our County Commissioner and HCFCD resulting in Jersey Village’s receiving benefits in excess of $50 million for improvements of White Oak Bayou where originally none was scheduled. I believe the best way to work with HCFCD is to stay focused on the technical issues and forming relationships rather than adversarial dealings which can generate negative publicity.
Joan Johnson:
How well do you think the current city council and mayor have handled the restrictor issue?
I am not sure of all the reasons, but this problem has been going on for a long time. Based on my information, the first study was commissioned shortly after Tropical Storm Allison and the study was received in December, 2001. As the solution to this problem is not with just West University Place, I understand that the negotiations with Harris County, City of Houston, Southside Place and many other cities does take time, and they are not always on our timeline. I believe the City took the correct action in going ahead with the drainage improvements in 2003, even though they knew that a restrictor would be placed on the Poor Farm Ditch drainage. Proceeding with this project at that time meant that WUP paid only a small share, ($700,000) for the $8 Million Project . The rest of the project was paid for by Metro Funds as well as Harris County. This also meant that we were not just starting the construction once the restrictor issue was resolved. It is my understanding that City Council appointed our City Manager to negotiate drainage mitigation, which continues to today.
The City of West U has been notified that about 4.4 acre-feet of detention is available for purchase by the city for $403,700. If the city purchases the detention space, the restrictor at the end of the pipe at Poor Farm Ditch could be reduced by about 1/3. Do you think the city should take advantage of this opportunity?
Definitely, we need to purchase this detention acreage while it is available. I understand this can be accomplished without incurring additional long term debt.
What other steps should be taken to remove the last 2/3 of the restrictor?”
We need to immediate research all of the alternatives that are available to us to complete this drainage project. I understand that there may be more than one solution and we need to analyze options and move ahead. As a City Council Member, this would be of utmost importance to me.
Dick Yehle:
My understanding is that the City initially tried to secure full use of the new sewer without committing additional money for detention. Had that worked, they would have been heroes. Since it did not and reflecting with 20/20 hindsight on the time lost and how the negotiations were handled, flaws are easy to find.
However, now that a decision has been taken by Harris County Flood Control that the City is responsible for detention, West U should move quickly to secure the 4.4 acre-feet that has been offered. The City should also investigate the feasibility and economics of alternative detention sites such as Kilmarnock Ditch and the possibility of trading the Ruffino Hills property for qualifying detention elsewhere in the Brays watershed.
There has been a lot of attention to the “restrictor issue” and for the sake of the affected “College Street” residents, it should be addressed forthwith. However, a broader focus should be taken on flood control for the sake of the more than 800 West U homes that are in the 100-year flood plain, both for the protection of those properties and to reduce the cost of flood insurance. With up to 800 people paying an extra $1,000 per year for flood insurance, there is a real justification for taking steps to ease the problem.
Jim Shields:
A wise politician said, “When presented with new facts, I change my mind; what do you do?”
This week, city manager Mike Ross, sent startling new facts to all of us candidates. Mr. Ross asked our engineers to prepare a table showing the effects of the restrictor on the College St. flood area (see my blog http://bungalowboyforwestu.blogspot.com/ for the table). The data are clear. There is no real measurable difference on flood levels whether there is a full restrictor, a partial restrictor, or no restrictor.
Given these new facts I am sure that all of us agree that not one more nickel should be spent on any measures to remove the restrictor – at least not until we know more facts. I am confident that the three city council incumbents who are candidates in this election will not bring the issue to a vote in the lame duck session. To do so would be shameful.
It is clear to me that the current mayor and city council have been kept in the dark. The engineering study released this week should have been done when the restrictor issue arose last year. Commissioner Radack urged Mr. Ross to tell the truth about the restrictor in December. Engineering studies must not be politicized.
I promise to be a prudent steward of our city, its people and its resources. Prudence dictates that we not waste money on useless projects.


April 22, 2011 at 3:24 pm
Mr. Shields, how dare you say we should get the same flood protection you already have? Shame on you! You say “no real measurable difference” if the restrictor is removed. Are you nuts? According to your table, my street water level drop about 12 inches when the restrictor is removed. That is a HUGE difference. You want to deprive us of the protection you already have. How unfair. We are tired of waiting and want the restrictor off now.
April 22, 2011 at 11:16 pm
I never said you should not have flood protection.
My one and only point is that we should not spend money on anything which will not help you
Jim
April 22, 2011 at 3:42 pm
Thank you Instant News for providing this forum. This answers to this question are useful to me. It has helped me eliminate one candidate from consideration.
April 22, 2011 at 4:06 pm
Jim: It sounds like you are the only one who was surprised by the engineer’s table that was released last week. Every other candidate didn’t seemed shock by the information, so for everyone else it does not appear to be new information. All the other candidates seem to share the approach that removing the restrictor is the appropriate course of action. It sounds to me like the other candidates were already informed on this and you are learning about the flooding issue for the first time. This is about people’s houses Jim. This is not a board game. Don’t be a know-it-all.
April 22, 2011 at 11:17 pm
would you change your mind if you find out that this information was sent to the candidates on April 18th?
Jim
April 22, 2011 at 4:15 pm
The matter of purchasing the mitigation space from HCFCD is on the agenda for Monday night. I highly recommend all interested citizens come. Our engineers will be there to explain what, if any, benefit really comes from removing all or part of the restrictors….as well as if the drainage system in place will really solve the flooding problems in the College Street area. I for one look forward to their answers to these questions.
April 22, 2011 at 4:25 pm
PS. I understand Dan Krocker, a resident of the College Street area who has kept on top of the flooding problems in his area, will attend Monday’s meeting as he is very concerned about what seems to be shown on our engineers study as to what may be and what not may be the benefits of removing the restrictors.
April 22, 2011 at 4:27 pm
We want to thank 7 of 8 of you for understanding our plight and committing to support the removal of the restrictor as soon as possible. And Mr. Shields, you are flat wrong: A 1 inch drop in water level is a “measurable difference” if we don’t remove the restrictor and your house draws an inch of water in a flood. I will not vote for anyone who has cold feet about removing the restrictor.
April 22, 2011 at 11:19 pm
Lighthouse
this is not a question about having cold feet. I want to spend our money on projects that will help. The engineers tell us that this will have minimal effect.
Insisting on a cost/benefit analysis does not constitute cold feet nor does it indicate I don’t care about the affected homeowners.
April 22, 2011 at 4:40 pm
Lighthouse: the City’s engineers will address the matter of “real” benefits in the removing all or part at the meeting Mon night. Please be there as it should prove very informative.
April 22, 2011 at 4:45 pm
Mr. Shields, unless your house has flooded (mine 3 times since 97) you are wrong about spending more to prevent flooding in this area. First of all we were not told the truth about the “PLUG”. If we had known the truth, we would have pursued this problem before now.
The City should have taken care of this long ago. Pay the million plus now. Now part of W.U is in the Flood Plain. Really? Now we have to finally think about the other 700+ Houses in W.U. MY! MY! The City Manager and Radack need to grow up. I attended the HCFCD meeting years ago. The representive stated mitigation would have to occur before anything could be done about the flooding in W.U.,South Side and Bellaire ( Developed back in the 1920″s or so). I questioned if any mitigation had been done before development of Braeswood area and all the other developments up stream.
I didn’t get an answer. It is all about developers and money. “Show me the MONEY” !!!!!! My Harris County Tax bill keeps going up!!!!
MITIGATION should be mandatory before any developement, Period!!!!!!
These City and County Officials need a degree in Common Sense.
April 22, 2011 at 4:45 pm
Bob Kelly, why are you acting like you are hearing all this for the first time? Have you been paying attention? It is long past time to remove that restrictor. You were all for it until you found out we are going to have to pay for it. You don’t have a flow restrictor for your house on Plumb. I don’t have a flow restrictor for my House on Tangley. So how in the Hell can you justify NOT removing the water flow restrictor for our fellow WestUies near College Street?
April 22, 2011 at 11:21 pm
Tangley
I don’t follow your logic. New facts were presented to us on April 18th.
As I said, when I get new facts I change my mind, what do you do?
Jim
April 26, 2011 at 11:58 am
That’s pretty snippy.
April 26, 2011 at 3:01 pm
Jim, Are Bob Kelly? You answered as though you were Bob Kelly.
April 22, 2011 at 5:55 pm
Did these same city engineers referred to above advise on placement of exhaust system at the new rec center? I assume so. If not, why weren’t they consulted? And if they were, why did they green light a system that drove the neigbors nuts and had to be moved at some expense? And still needs to be moved again according to some folks living in the area.
It’s a simple question. But I will repeat it. Are these the same “city engineers” that gave approval on the initial exhaust system at the rec center?
How about a simple yes or not answer? Thanks.
April 22, 2011 at 5:56 pm
I have a few basic questions. Why was there a restrictor placed in 2003 that wasn’t there before? What was its correlation to the drainage improvements. If the water leaves West U quickly and we don’t flood that is great. Where does the water go – downhill I assume? Was the restrictor placed to balance or offset the massive drainage systems we put in place? If not, then why would anyone deliberately dam up flood water. If we deserve the drainage, then there shouldn’t be any question and we shouldn’t owe anyone money. If we don’t, is it because someone out there is looking at a bigger picture.
Last question – what were the “mitigation terms” that the City of WUP made with Metro and Harris County? I don’t feel like we have all the facts.
April 22, 2011 at 7:40 pm
Mr Shields:
I can only assume you have never had your home flooded or even come close. Those of us that live on the 3800 block of Southwestern can assure you that 3.1 inches (difference in water level between No Restrictor & Full Restrictor as shown on your blog) is a BIG difference. We have seen the water lapping at our doorway after just a hard rain and another 1-2 inches of water level would have meant being flooded again! The table shows Riley St. to have an even bigger difference!
And where exactly on Southwestern St., Riley St, Marquette St. etc. did they measure this difference? Was it on the corner of College & the street in question?..or center of 3800 block?..or center of 3900 block?..or at the end of the 3800 block where most of the flooding occurs?
I also question what engineers did these reports? The same ones that did the evaluations and drawings for our present “new” system that Commissioner Radack now says is inferior (refer to recorded conversations with Ross).
The residents whose homes have flooded and risk flooding again (and are paying almost another $2000 a year for flood insurance) have a hard time understanding your “don’t spend another nickel” position when almost half a million dollars was just spent on additional parking for the new city building (which also has incurred many unneeded additional dollars of debt).
Shame on you for being so insensitive to residents in need and you aren’t even in office already. OR, are you hedging your votes by appealing to other residents that aren’t affected by flooding issues?
April 22, 2011 at 8:23 pm
When you say “or at the end of the 3800 block where most of the flooding occurs” are you talking about say, 3843 which would be at the corner of College and an intersecting street.” I just used 3843 to show which direction, east or west of the middle of the 3800 Block. Does most of the flooding run from Riley to Swarthmore on both sides of College? Does the water flow as far down the 3900 Block as the 3800 Block. I think they should bring in some engineers now, paid for by the County and/or West University and find out what is causing the failure to drain. Take advantage of this dry weather and lower cameras and run it the length of the sewers. They talk like removing the restrictor won’t help much. Must be someone out there who knows what is going on. Its been ten years since Allison and its time to figure it out. Since they are cutting the space program, which I do regret, why don’t they use some of that talent to work on the country’s infrastructure challenges. Hang in there!!
April 22, 2011 at 9:32 pm
Come get the answers Monday night. The City’s recent engineering study has raised many questions. We need to solve the College Street flooding problems.. We can solve this problem once and for all. Be there and hear the answers.
April 22, 2011 at 9:46 pm
PS. Ok all you blogers. Monday night you will get your chance to put your Council on the line. As the Mayor, and as such the one who controls the meeting, you will get the chance to put our City engineers and Council on the line. Get your questions ready. I promise you that before the City commits aother million + dollars in an effort to solve the flooding problems in the College Street area it will be cost effect, or you will know who to blame if it doesn’t. The gloves are off, now is the time to get the problem really fixed.
April 22, 2011 at 9:59 pm
Funny, putting all your faith in engineers who were ignored about the basement issues . . . . Sometimes I wonder if you politicians just hear what you want to hear.
April 22, 2011 at 11:26 pm
El Paso
Good point
I am still scratching my head over the council’s vote to ignore the two commissions they hired study the basement issue.
It looks like the 3 incumbents will ignore the engineers they hired to study the effect of the restrictor.
Why are they behaving so irrationally?
Jim
April 22, 2011 at 11:41 pm
But the report specifically says that on certain blocks, the removal of the restrictor can help.
April 22, 2011 at 10:02 pm
Mayor, you are the one who has screwed this deal up. You are the LAST person I trust to find a resolution. I will come to the meeting on Monday. But I will not listen to you blow smoke up our a*s again. We trusted you before. You fooled me once…but not again.
April 22, 2011 at 11:28 pm
Byron Street
Mayor Kelly is the only one speaking clearly on this issue. See my comments above and go to my blog.
I have a pretty good smoke detector and a lot of smoke is being blown my way, buy its not from Kelly.
Jim
April 22, 2011 at 10:26 pm
El Paso, keep in mind who ignored the engineers and who didn’t. I was the only one who did not. I am term limited, and am frustrated that the Collegee street flooding problem has not been solved. I am not trying to get elected. I feel for those in the College Street area. But I do not want to throw another 1 million of our tax papers dollars at the situation unless it really helps solve their flooding problem. Come Monday night and ask Council and the City enginneers just questions. Let’s let the chips fall where they may.
April 22, 2011 at 10:48 pm
These responses are truly stunning. The numbers on the table speak for themselves. The footnote to the table says that the the assumption was made that Braes Bayou would not be in a flood condition. That is quite an assumption.
I am against wasting money on a project that will offer no relief to the flooding that takes place in the College St storm sewer project. I care about the homeowners and it is cruel to give them false hope.
Does anyone think that removing the restrictor will convince flood insurers to offer flood insurance to the affected homes, given the study done by our own engineers?
I have spent a considerable amount of time trying to gather the facts. The table with the numbers came out on April 18, 2011. Who told you this is old data? This is new information. I consulted 2 engineers and they confirmed that the effect of the restrictor is negligible.
Riley St will be positively affected to a small extent but the rest of the homes will be in the same shape with the restrictor in place as they would be by removing the entire restrictor.
I am convinced that it would be a betrayal of the public trust to spend one more nickel on removing the restrictor unless and until more facts are known?
Common sense and good judgment matter. I am very dismayed that the seven other candidates are choosing to ignore the facts.
If the three incumbents vote to spend the $403K they should be ashamed.
Everyone should know that the possibility of being able to purchase the remaining land ($800,000 more)to remove the restrictor is a long way off. Anyone who tells you differently is fooling you.
Engineering issues aside, this is a political problem. It is a complicated problem. We did ourselves no favor when our city manager secretly taped phone conversations he had with our County Commissioner. Anyone who claims that this did not put us into a deep political hole is fooling you.
I don’t know what the solution to the flooding problem is. So far as I can tell, no one else has offered a solution.
I am quite certain that removing the restrictor will not help. I am anxiuos to find out what the other seven candidates know that I don’t know.
April 22, 2011 at 11:01 pm
Southwestern
I think you agree with me. I am absolutely for spending money to help the folks in the College St flood area. I am opposed to wasting money on a project which will do no good.
You are correct that all of us have been kept in the dark regarding flood issues. That much has been made very clear to me in the last month that I have been studying the issue.
When you talk to people who should know the history, many different stories crop up. I will not pass on the many rumors I have heard. I will stick to the facts that I can verify and check out.
I have checked out the numbers on the recent engineering study. I am baffled why I seem to be the only person alarmed by those numbers.
College St area rez
I will have to say that a condition for making decisions about this issue is having to have lived through a flood is plain wrong. Are you saying that only people who live in the affected area can be allowed to decide?
Jim
April 22, 2011 at 11:15 pm
West U Gilbert
would you change your mind if you were convinced that the other seven candidates found out about this on April 18th when I did?
April 22, 2011 at 11:20 pm
Jim:
When you announced you were runnning, this is what the story said:
“Current council members that Shields said he respects are Mayor Pro Tem Bob Fry and Councilmember Steven Segal.“I hope to be like them,” he said, adding that both are seasoned, educated men.”
Does it concern you that both of these men you say you respect so much have studied this issue for a term of years and both completely disagree with you?
The only person who seems to agree with you is our lovely lame-duck mayor, who happens to be the clown who got us in this mess. We are making progress. Either help us get this restictor off or step aside.
April 22, 2011 at 11:44 pm
Byron Street
I am totally baffled by the responses of Bob and Steve. I said so at the candidate forum at Krogers.
It does concern me that we are looking at the same data and come to different solutions.
My son in law has a PhD from Berkeley in Environmental Management specializing in water management. He is an expert in hydrology and reviewed the table in question. He said that, save for Riley St, the restrictor has very minimal effect on the rest of the flood basin in College St.
I do want to stress that every engineer I talked to emphasized the point that hydrology is very complicated. It is my opinion that the College St flood basin is man made. From what I can determine, a variety of projects in surrounding streets and developments created and artificial “lake” in that area. This is not good news to the homeowners but it does point to the fact that everything is interconnected in the Harris County
flood plain.
Think for a minute. What if the discharge opening for the College St storm sewer at the Poor Farm Ditch was oversized? Engineers typically do that to allow for future expansion. This would make the restrictor inconsequential as the engineering study shows.
Why then would the county insist that a restrictor be installed in the first place? Can you think of a reason? I can. And it has nothing to do with engineering but has everything to do with politics. There are plenty of neighbors to our south who ar up in arms over the College St storm sewer.
Is this plausible to you?
Jim
April 23, 2011 at 5:40 am
Look at me!! It’s 5:30 AM on Easter Saturday and I am typing on this blog. I assure you folks that this is not normal for me.
This is the first time running for political office. Common sense and good judgment matter is a theme I have been trying to emphasize.
When I was in the Corps of Engineers I was at a meeting about base closures. One of my fellow officers asked the presiding general,”sir, we know exactly which bases to close and have known for years, what is the problem?”
The general said something very obvious which has stuck with me all these years. He said, “son, you are arguing on the playing field of reason and logic. You will win all day long on that playing field. But this game isn’t being played on the field of reason and logic. It is being played on the field of politics. Never confuse the two.”
So yes, common sense tells me that using arguments of reason and logic are of little use when political concerns are foremost.
Look at the responses above by the other candidates. I said that all of us were presented with new facts on April 18th. I changed my my mind regarding the restrictor based on these new facts. That is what reason and logic demand.
Now look at the responses. Because I based my decision on reason and logic, I don’t care about the residents who live in the flood basin.
I am not qualified to make decisions because I have never been flooded myself.
I must be out of touch because out of eight people running, I am the only one to reach this conclusion.
If I were to switch to the playing field of politics like everyone else, my response would be the same as everyone else’s.
Even though common sense tells me that I am arguing on the wrong playing field, good judgment tells me that is plain wrong. I choose to stay with the facts.
If you want a politician, don’t vote for me.
with respect
Jim
April 23, 2011 at 6:06 am
I know that very few people read this blog and what I say here is of little consequence but it is good practice for me to get feedback from those of you who do read here.
What follows is speculation by me. It is an argument based on assumed facts. If my assumptions are wrong, this argument is wrong. Got that?
Here goes.
First, some relevant facts. One of the strategies used by hydrologists is to lower street levels so that streets essentially become catchment basins . Another fact is that metro money was used for the College St project and other flood abatement projects. Note – that money is not monopoly money as some politicians have said, but that is the subject of another rant.
Now my speculation. The area in question is bounded on three sides by metro bus routes – University, Weslayan, and Bellaire. I suspect that those streets were not lowered because it would hamper mobility – and Metro would not intentionally make a bus route a catchment basin.
The fourth boundary is Southside Place and they did not lower their streets.
In other words, a little lake was formed by competing flood abatement tactics.
Second fact. The original contractor responsible for installing the sewer in the College St flood basin went broke and went out of business before the completion of the project.
Speculation. Before the contractor was forced off the project, he used sub standard (smaller) sewer pipe to save money. He covered up his intentional error before the inspector could sign off and political forces demanded that the project be not be held up any longer. The natives were becoming restless with torn up streets. A huge problem is buried underground.
There is some reason for me to believe that this is more than speculation but I am not in a position at this time to call it more than speculation.
But isn’t there some indication that we may not know all of the facts. It would be an easy matter to disprove my speculation.
Why is there this rush to immediately spend $400,000 on a project that probably won’t work?
If y’all know something I don’t, please tell me. I will be happy to change my mind again. My opinion changes with the facts. As they change, I change. What do you do?
thanks for responding even if you shift to the playing field of politics
Jim
April 23, 2011 at 8:21 am
Jim:
I think you will fnd that the contractor who went belly up didn’t even do any construction in the College Street area. Where do get this misinformation? Please stop spouting off stuff without facts. You are really harming people and their investments ny jumping in without facts. Get your facts FIRST, BEFORE you start typing.
April 23, 2011 at 8:40 am
Jim, about everything you and the Mayor say are wrong. For one thing the information in the report you post on your blog is not exactly new. George Bohme (Councilmember) told me after one of the meetings many months ago (I think in December) that I needed to understand that taking the restrictor off would not keep our streets from flooding or solve all the problems. But he said we did need to remove the restrictor because it was the only way we would get the full use of the system. And that is basically what the report you quote says.
Jim, it sounds like you would have been a lot better off if you had been getting your information from Bohme instead of Bob Kelly. I called Boehme and talked to him on Friday. He understands this issue and he told me that all the other candidates except for Jim have taken the time to educate themselves on this issue. He also told me both of the mayor candidates have a total grasp of the issue. But if any of my College Street area neighbors really want to talk about this you should call Councilmember Bohme at 713.662.5848. I think that is a city hall number that forwards to his cell phone. He really does understand this stuff. Jim, you should call him and get a briefing about what is really going on.
April 23, 2011 at 8:50 am
Byron Bungalow
I’ve talked to George before. I’ll pass.
I would however like to hear Mike Ross comment on my post below.
Jim
April 23, 2011 at 8:56 am
Byron Bungalow
I apologize for being so flippant. You wrote:
“George Bohme (Councilmember) told me after one of the meetings many months ago (I think in December) that I needed to understand that taking the restrictor off would not keep our streets from flooding or solve all the problems. But he said we did need to remove the restrictor because it was the only way we would get the full use of the system.”
Does that statement make sense to you? George essentially says that the restrictor does no good but we need to remove it. And he knew this in December. Why stay silent for so long?
Jim
April 23, 2011 at 9:14 am
I should have said that essentially George admitted that the rescrictor does no harm.
April 23, 2011 at 9:19 am
Jim, listen to youself? George was not silent. He told the guy back in December. What George is saying (and had told me several times going back to before December) is that people were being led by some to think that taking the restrictor off would solve “every” problem. And he has said that you will still have street flooding and still have issues during another Allison. The Mayor sold us a bill of goods by saying restrictor removal would be the cure in itself. My memory is that the Mayor is the ONLY person at city hall who has ever said that and Mayor Kelly was always wrong.
And Jim, the a 11 inch drop on Byron when the restrictor is removed is very substanitive. In fact even a few inches is quite substanitive. You just don’t know what you are talking about.
Keep in mind, I don’t live off College Street, but we need to do the right thing and remove the restrictor.
April 23, 2011 at 8:43 am
Good Government
Gotcha. I inserted this “fact” to see if anyone is listening.
The undersized sized pipe was discovered and replaced. You are correct.
Mike Ross – if this is you responding, please don’t remain in hiding. Come out and give us the facts. I for one will base my decisions on facts.
Can you tell me
1. Is the opening at the discharge into Poor Farm Ditch oversized? That would explain why the engineering study shows that the restrictor is inconsequential.
2.Are my assumptions about the man made lake correct?
If you, “Good Government,” are really Mike Ross, please let us know. You corrected the only intentionally false statement I made. Does this mean you agree with everything else I said?
Jim
April 23, 2011 at 8:54 am
No, Jim, I am not Michael Ross. I live on Wakeforest. But you now admit that you knowingly lied on this website. You are off your rocker.
April 23, 2011 at 9:03 am
I was being prudent. Indeed I knowingly lied to see if anyone who knows the facts is reading here. It didn’t take me long to find out did it?
Does your silence on my other comments indicate that you have no further facts to offer?
I admit that I only became concerned about the restrictor in December. I wrote a letter to the papers reporting on the issue asking for clarification. But you will remember the papers were making a big deal of Mike Ross secretly taping phone calls.
When I decided to enter the race in March, I started doing my homework. You seem to know some facts. Please weigh in. I love dealing with facts.
Jim
April 23, 2011 at 9:08 am
So the expert you quote is your son-in-law, THEODORE GRANTHAM? If so, his honors thesis is on the “Changes of migration patterns of Baltic and Siberian barnacle geese (Branta leucopsis) staging in the German Wadden Sea.Changes of migration patterns of Baltic and Siberian barnacle geese (Branta leucopsis) staging in the German Wadden Sea.”
Just what we need: a Berkley environmentalist to tell us how to build our streets in West U.
April 23, 2011 at 9:16 am
This is my son in law
http://ecnr.berkeley.edu/vfs/PPs/Grantham-TheE/web/cv.pdf
Like you said, get your facts correct before you start typing.
Jim
April 23, 2011 at 9:22 am
Good Government
I see what you are up to. Ted wrote an honors thesis when he was at Stanford a decade ago about birds. His PhD work at Berkeley reads.
“My research is focused on the hydrological and ecological processes that influence stream ecosystems, and how the
maintenance of natural flow regimes can be integrated in restoration practice and water management policy. My current
research interests include the identification of ecological flow requirements for salmonids, modeling stream hydraulics
at ecologically-relevant scales, and the development of management frameworks to balance human and ecosystem
water needs in Mediterranean-climate regions. The overall objective of my work is to improve our ability to predict the
outcomes of river restoration and water resource management through the integrated study of ecology and hydrology.”
You seem to have disdain for Berkeley environmentalists. What universities are acceptable to you?
Ted is now a Fulbright scholar at the University of Barcelona.
Jim
April 23, 2011 at 9:24 am
So my facts are correct:
Honors thesis: Changes of migration patterns of Baltic and Siberian barnacle geese (Branta leucopsis) staging in the German Wadden Sea.
http://ecnr.berkeley.edu/vfs/PPs/Grantham-TheE/web/cv.pdf
Jim and Kelly must be related, both of you disregard all facts. I am leaving to go to the ZOO with my grandkids. Good Holiday to all. Over and out.
April 23, 2011 at 10:15 am
I like the man-made lake theory. If the College area street south of University was lowered, and Weslayan,and University were not and the Southside Place wall extends the length of Auden, that could just explain the lake effect. Now I lived on College and Marlowe. Our College Street section was lowered, I know that for a fact because we didn’t have curbs before the infrastructure work that ended in 1999 and the street was as high as my yard. Weslayan north of University was not lowered. We were saved because most of the streets between Bissonnet and University open into Auden. (There are a couple of streets that dead end and don’t open into Auden.)Something has to be done. That whole section is very nice and can’t be just written off. If West U isn’t careful, there will be a shift from a residential neighborhood to a commercial neighborhood. I’m implying that if this large section of residential housing is replaced with construction that can deal with the lower topography (I looked that up.) it would be commercial development. They sure wouldn’t build houses with basements. The area will slowly deteriorate and the city won’t have the money to buy out the owners who have moved somewhere else and are renting the property. I don’t understand why the professionals who planned all this didn’t see the flaws in the great plan.
April 23, 2011 at 10:47 am
From Good Government:
Just what we need: a Berkley environmentalist to tell us how to build our streets in West U.
Well, someone needs to. I’m going shopping.
April 24, 2011 at 6:49 pm
Here is what Mr. Shields says above, in his own words.”I was being prudent. Indeed I knowingly lied to see if anyone who knows the facts is reading here.”
There is nothing I can add,
April 25, 2011 at 5:44 pm
As I have said before, Pay the 1.plus million. Problem solved. No, I guess we need to have more cute “Street Lights”, “Crazy sidewalks” and a few more “Poor Mans River Oaks Country Clubs” (We have Two now). The City knew about the “Plug” as far back as 2007. Citizens were not told until this past November. Shame Shame!!!!!. Now look who is talking about Commom Sence????????? “Good Judgement”??????????????? New Police Station??? What next???
Please Pay the 1.plus Million, before it starts raining.Plleeeeese!